Key Findings from the 2013 NAEP State Mapping Analysis
Key Findings
The following are the key findings regarding state proficiency standards as they are measured on the NAEP scale.
Grade 4

In reading, the difference in NAEP equivalent scores between the states with the highest and lowest proficiency standards is about 76 points on the NAEP 0500 scale. This difference is about twice the size of the standard deviation on the NAEP national grade 4 reading assessment (37 points) and more than twice the 30point difference between
Basic and
Proficient performance levels for NAEP grade 4 reading.

In mathematics, the range of NAEP equivalent scores from the state with the lowest to the state with the highest proficiency standards is 49 points on the NAEP 0500 scale, about one and a half times the size of the standard deviation of the NAEP mathematics scores for public school students (30 points) and about one and a half times the 35point difference between
Basic and
Proficient performance on NAEP set for grade 4.
Grade 8

In reading, the difference in NAEP equivalent scores between the states with the highest and lowest proficiency standards is 83 points on the NAEP 0500 scale. The difference is about twice the size of the standard deviation on the NAEP national grade 8 reading assessments (34 points) and about twice the 38point difference between
Basic and
Proficient performance on NAEP set for grade 8.

In mathematics, the 60point distance separating the highest and lowest proficiency standards is about one and a half times the size of the standard deviation of the NAEP mathematics scores for public school students (36 points) and one and a half times the 37point distance between NAEP Basic and Proficient performance set for grade 8 mathematics.
Although the wide variation in standards persists, the number of states with grade 4 reading standards at or above the NAEP
Basic level increased from 15 in 2009 and 20 in 2011 to 25 in 2013. Although in 2009 and 2011 no state standard was in the NAEP
Proficient range, in 2013 two states had grade 4 reading standards in that range. In mathematics, the number of states with grade 4 standards at or above the NAEP
Basic level also increased, from 44 in 2009 to 46 in 2011 and 47 in 2013, with five states having standards in the
Proficient range in 2013 compared with one state each in 2009 and 2011.
At grade 8, the number of states with reading standards at or above the NAEP
Basic level increased from 35 in 2009 and 36 in 2011 to 41 in 2013 (with one state standard in the
Proficient range in 2013 compared with none in the previous years). In mathematics, 41 out of 49 states included in the study had standards above the NAEP
Basic level, and increase from 39 both in 2009 and 2011; three of these state standards were also above the
Proficient level, compared with one state standard in 2009 and two in 2011.
Back to the Top
State Profiles
The 2013 State Mapping report is supplemented by a survey that was conducted to gain contextual information about the general characteristics of a state's assessment program, and to identify any changes in that program since 2011 that could affect the interpretation of the 2013 mapping results.
Download your state's profile to see information about the methodology of this survey and results for your state.
Back to the Top
Summary Data Tables
State Standards from 2009 to 2013
NAEP corroborating statereported changes in student achievement from 2005 to 2009

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 4 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2013

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 8 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2013

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 4 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2011

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 8 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2011

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 4 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2009

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results in grades 8 and percentage of the student population represented in these comparison schools, by subject and state: 2009

Percentages of students meeting state proficiency standards and performing at or above the NAEP Proficient level, by grade, subject, and state: 2013

Percentages of students meeting state proficiency standards and performing at or above the NAEP Proficient level, by grade, subject, and state: 2011

Percentages of students meeting state proficiency standards and performing at or above the NAEP Proficient level, by grade, subject, and state: 2009
Additional Information from 2009 to 2013
State standards from 2005 to 2009
Change in standards from 2005 to 2009
Change in standards from 2007 to 2009
NAEP corroborating statereported changes in student achievement from 2005 to 2009
NAEP corroborating statereported changes in student achievement from 2007 to 2009
Additional information from 2005 to 2009

Correlations between NAEP and state assessment schoollevel percentages meeting the proficient standard, by subject, grade, and state: 2009

Percentage of NAEP schools available for comparing state assessment results with NAEP results, by subject, grade, and state: 2009

Comparability and availability of the 2009 state assessment results with the 2005 reported results, by subject, grade, and state

Comparability and availability of the 2009 state assessment results with the 2007 reported results, by subject, grade, and state
Back to the Top
Last updated 13 August 2015 (DS)